Sharing knowledge

Beyond the hype: choosing between PowerPoint and VR/AR for effective learning

September 24, 2024
6 minutes
Ferenc Boroczky
Founder and CEO of anet360

When I was growing up in Hungary during the 1990s and early 2000s, our options for studying were pretty straightforward — books, pens, and paper were the main tools at our disposal. This was a time when the digital revolution was just starting to influence education but in a very limited way.

After moving to the UK and attending Birkbeck University of London and then the Open University in the 2010s, I noticed some changes, but not as many as you might think. Sure, we had PowerPoint to present our ideas, and we occasionally watched videos, but the core of learning still revolved around traditional methods. Augmented Reality /Virtual Reality technology, which is now on the brink of transforming education, was then just a distant concept.

This journey through different educational landscapes has shown me that the real challenge isn't just in acknowledging that AR/VR can be beneficial, but in finding ways to integrate these technologies into learning environments effectively. It’s about building confidence among users — students and educators alike — and knowing when and how to apply these tools to enhance learning outcomes. As we discuss the potential of modern educational tools like AR and VR, let’s explore how we can transition from the familiar world of PowerPoint and textbooks to the immersive and interactive possibilities offered by new technology, ensuring that we use each tool appropriately to maximise its benefits.

The allure of VR/AR: fun and interactive

VR and AR turn learning into an interactive experience. Imagine learning about the Roman Empire by walking through virtual ancient Rome or exploring the human body in 3D. These technologies make you feel like you're part of the lesson, which can make learning a lot more exciting.

Image credit
Why stick with PowerPoint?

Despite the excitement around VR and AR, PowerPoint has its own strengths. It’s simple, clear, and gets the job done. Studies, like one from Jocelyn Parong and Richard E. Mayer at the University of California, Santa Barbara, show that students can actually learn better from a well-made PowerPoint than from a VR session. The structure and straightforward information help students remember and understand better. (Source

The study mentioned earlier also found something interesting: while VR made learning more fun and engaging, it didn’t always improve test scores. However, when VR lessons were broken into parts with summaries, students not only enjoyed learning but also remembered more. This tells us that mixing old and new methods — like using both VR and PowerPoint — might be the best way to both excite and educate students.

The choice between PowerPoint and VR/AR depends on what you need:
  1. Complex topics: If the topic is complex or abstract, VR/AR can make it easier to understand by letting you explore it in a hands-on way.
  2. Focus on remembering: If you need to make sure students remember the information, PowerPoint’s clear and direct format might work better.
  3. What’s available: not everyone has access to fancy VR gear, so PowerPoint can be a more practical choice in many situations.
Blending the Best of Both

Looking ahead, the goal isn’t to pick one tool over the other, but to use both in ways that make learning better. By combining the excitement of VR with the clarity of PowerPoint, we can give students both fun and understanding. Let’s be thoughtful about how we use technology in education. It’s not about chasing the latest gadget but about finding new ways to make learning better. We should pick technologies like VR not just because they’re cool, but because they add real value to education.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322708154_Learning_Science_in_Immersive_Virtual_Reality

Subscribe to anet360 Insights

Get industry insights that you won't delete, straight in your inbox.
We use contact information you provide to us to contact you about our relevant content, products, and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. For information, check out our Privacy Policy.
Ferenc Boroczky
Founder and CEO of anet360
With more than 15 years in design and technology focused on people, I've dedicated myself to growing a business that makes a real difference. I'm the Founder and CEO of Another Set of Eyes (anet), a company my wife and I built from scratch. We've come a long way without financial backing from investors, proving our resilience and innovation and developing a high-quality, yet user-friendly software solution. Our mission is to change how organizations gather and use important information, share insights, and train their teams.

More news

Company announcements

From kitchen porter to global brands: the journey behind our new Safe Rider training app

Today, we’re excited to announce the launch of Version 3.0 of our product. While it may seem like just another update to some, for us, it holds much deeper significance. This version is a reflection of the growing demand for our solutions and the increasing appetite for innovative, easy-to-use tools that help professional drivers upskill, improve their digital skills, and embrace new learning methods.

Read Article
Company announcements

Announcing the successful launch of the Antrim and Newtownabbey Virtual Reality Driver Training Program

We are proud to announce the successful launch of a groundbreaking driver training solution for the Antrim and Newtownabbey Borough Council in Northern Ireland. This innovative program, designed by our team at anet360, utilizes state-of-the-art virtual reality technology to transform the way driving skills are taught and refined within the council.

Read Article
Sharing knowledge

From intuitive fixes to eye tracking insights: The new frontier of knowledge sharing

While eye-tracking technology might seem costly at first glance, its ability to capture and analyse where and how experts focus their attention during critical tasks justifies the investment.

Read Article